Exodus 17:4

Exodus 17:4

ESV: So Moses cried to the LORD, "What shall I do with this people? They are almost ready to stone me."

KJV: And Moses cried unto the LORD, saying, What shall I do unto this people? they be almost ready to stone me.

NIV: Then Moses cried out to the LORD, "What am I to do with these people? They are almost ready to stone me."

NKJV: So Moses cried out to the LORD, saying, "What shall I do with this people? They are almost ready to stone me!"

NLT: Then Moses cried out to the LORD, "What should I do with these people? They are ready to stone me!"

Meaning

Exodus 17:4 captures a critical moment of profound desperation for Moses. Faced with the immediate, murderous intent of the Israelite community due to their thirst and distrust in God's provision, Moses issues a desperate cry to the Lord. His plea, "What shall I do with this people? They are almost ready to stone me!" reveals his complete powerlessness against the rebellious mob and his ultimate reliance on the divine intervention of YHWH, the covenant-keeping God, to save both himself and the ungrateful people. It signifies the peak of the people's complaint, transforming into a violent threat against God's appointed leader.

Cross References

Context

Exodus 17:4 takes place during Israel's arduous journey through the wilderness after their miraculous escape from Egypt and the crossing of the Red Sea. Following their initial experience of manna and quail in the wilderness of Sin, the people arrive at Rephidim, a place severely lacking water. Their immediate and escalating response to this privation is not trust, but intense complaint and even quarreling with Moses, culminating in a violent threat against his life. This verse highlights the crisis point where the Israelites' faithlessness reaches a critical level, transitioning from mere murmuring to a full-blown demand that risks Moses' survival. This event, later named "Massah" (testing) and "Meribah" (quarrel) (Exo 17:7), exemplifies the consistent pattern of Israel testing the Lord, despite His faithful provision, and the heavy burden of leadership placed on Moses.

Word analysis

• So: Connects this urgent plea directly to the preceding events of the people's intense quarreling and the accusation that Moses had led them to perish from thirst (Exo 17:3). It shows Moses' reaction to the immediate, desperate situation.

• Moses: The appointed leader and mediator of God, yet here he stands utterly powerless before human rage, stripped of all personal resources to resolve the crisis. His leadership is under severe, mortal threat.

• cried out: (Hebrew: tsa'aq, צָעַק) – Implies a desperate, urgent, and loud appeal for help in the face of deep distress, oppression, or imminent danger. It is not a casual prayer but a passionate, immediate call for divine intervention when all human options are exhausted. It signifies an awareness of extreme peril and absolute dependence on God.

• to the Lord: (Hebrew: YHWH, יהוה, often read as Adonai) – Moses' appeal is not to human authority or his own wit, but to the covenant God who has repeatedly proven faithful. This demonstrates his spiritual leadership, turning to the only true source of deliverance and authority in a crisis that transcends human solutions.

• "What shall I do...": This rhetorical question expresses extreme perplexity, powerlessness, and the overwhelming weight of the situation. It highlights Moses' utter inability to control the situation or appease the enraged mob. It is a surrender of human strategy and an immediate turning to divine counsel.

• "...with this people?": Reflects Moses' exasperation and the immense burden he carries. The phrase can convey a sense of 'these' difficult, stubborn, rebellious people, identifying them distinctively by their behavior and challenging Moses' ability to lead them.

• "They are almost ready...": Emphasizes the imminence of the danger. The threat is not theoretical but on the verge of execution, showing the heightened state of rebellion and violence. This phrase conveys a palpable sense of danger and urgency.

• "...to stone me!": Stoning was a severe form of punishment in ancient Israel, often for grave offenses like idolatry or blasphemy. Here, it signifies an act of mob violence and utter rejection of Moses' divine authority, bordering on apostasy as they implicitly reject the God who works through Moses. It represents a murderous intent and the ultimate human repudiation of leadership and divine intervention.

• Words-group Analysis:

  • "Moses cried out to the Lord": This phrase captures the essence of a righteous leader's response in a crisis – turning from human solutions and popular pressure to immediate, desperate, and dependent prayer to God, recognizing His supreme authority and ability to act. It establishes a pattern for true spiritual leadership.
  • "'What shall I do with this people?'": This question articulates the profound helplessness of even a divinely appointed leader when confronted by persistent human rebellion and overwhelming popular discontent. It underscores that leadership's effectiveness ultimately relies on divine wisdom and power, not merely human skill.
  • "They are almost ready to stone me!": This statement reveals the depth of the people's discontent and their descent into mob rule, where their grumbling transitions from mere complaint to murderous intent. It showcases the severity of human unbelief and ingratitude, capable of turning violently against the very instruments of God's grace.

Commentary

Exodus 17:4 stands as a stark depiction of leadership under extreme duress and the relentless rebellion of the human heart against God. Moses, God's chosen deliverer, finds himself at the precipice of death, not at the hands of the Egyptians, but from the very people he is called to lead. His "crying out" to the Lord (a desperate tsa'aq) underscores his complete inability to manage the volatile situation and highlights his utter reliance on divine intervention. He doesn't formulate a plan, try to negotiate, or raise a defense; instead, he takes the crisis directly to the only one capable of handling it – YHWH. The people's threat of stoning reflects their total disregard for God's prior mighty works on their behalf, a failure to trust His continued provision, and a horrifying willingness to commit murder against His appointed servant. This event, later called "Massah" (testing of God by Israel) and "Meribah" (Israel's quarreling), became a critical point of remembrance for the Lord's patience and Israel's unbelief. Yet, remarkably, God's immediate response is not judgment, but the promise of provision, demonstrating His unyielding faithfulness even in the face of profound human faithlessness.

Bonus section

The profound desperation of Moses in this verse prefigures the challenges faced by many of God's chosen servants throughout biblical history. Prophets like Jeremiah were reviled and persecuted by their own people (Jer 1:19). The apostle Paul faced repeated stoning and attempts on his life for faithfully delivering God's message (Acts 14:19). Ultimately, Jesus Christ Himself was rejected by His own people and crucified, though He too cried out to God in His distress (Matt 27:46). Moses' plea here thus serves as an archetype of the often-lonely and perilous task of serving God amidst a resistant world. Furthermore, the divine provision of water from the rock, given shortly after this plea (Exo 17:6), later becomes a powerful symbol for Christ, the Spiritual Rock who provides living water to all who believe, even those who, in their unbelief, rejected Him. This moment of extreme crisis leads directly to a profound demonstration of God's grace.

Explore exodus 17 images, wallpapers, art, audio, video, maps, infographics and timelines