Numbers 11 13

Numbers 11:13

ESV: Where am I to get meat to give to all this people? For they weep before me and say, 'Give us meat, that we may eat.'

KJV: Whence should I have flesh to give unto all this people? for they weep unto me, saying, Give us flesh, that we may eat.

NIV: Where can I get meat for all these people? They keep wailing to me, 'Give us meat to eat!'

NKJV: Where am I to get meat to give to all these people? For they weep all over me, saying, 'Give us meat, that we may eat.'

NLT: Where am I supposed to get meat for all these people? They keep whining to me, saying, 'Give us meat to eat!'

Meaning

Numbers 11:13 encapsulates Moses' deep frustration and despair as the leader of Israel, facing the constant demands of the multitude. The people's persistent weeping for meat pushes Moses to the brink, causing him to question how he, a mere human, could possibly fulfill such an immense and unreasonable desire. It highlights the vast disconnect between human inability and the boundless needs of a nation, setting the stage for Moses to cry out to God for help.

Cross References

Context

The immediate context of Numbers chapter 11 opens with the Israelites complaining at Taberah, incurring God's judgment by fire. Despite this, a deeper wave of discontent emerges: "the rabble" (foreigners or mixed multitude) among them develops a strong craving for meat, influencing the native Israelites who also begin weeping, lamenting the absence of diverse foods they had in Egypt, contrasting it with the "light" diet of manna. Moses hears their incessant weeping and brings their complaint to the LORD in verses 10-12, expressing his profound personal distress and inadequacy. Verse 13 directly articulates Moses' feeling of overwhelming responsibility to provide for a nation whose demands far exceed his human capacity. Historically, Israel had been wandering in the wilderness for over a year since leaving Sinai, sustained entirely by God's miraculous manna. Their yearning for meat and familiar Egyptian provisions reflects a deep-seated lack of trust in God's daily, sustained care, revealing a carnal dissatisfaction with their divinely provided existence.

Word analysis

• Where am I to get: The Hebrew minnayin li (מִנַּיִן לִי) translates literally to "from where to me?" It's a rhetorical question expressing profound bewilderment, helplessness, and the perceived impossibility of a human solution. Moses is highlighting his complete lack of resources or means to fulfill such a demand. This underscores his desperate appeal, turning the people's complaint into his own direct, distressed question to God.
• meat: The Hebrew word is basar (בָּשָׂר), meaning "flesh" or "meat." In this context, it represents the physical craving of the people, their lustful desire (hit’avah) for a specific physical commodity. This stands in stark contrast to the spiritual nourishment provided by the manna, highlighting the people's preference for transient, worldly desires over the miraculous and sustained divine provision.
• to give all these people: This phrase emphasizes the vast scale of the problem. It's not just a few individuals but an entire multitude of hundreds of thousands, all demanding the same thing. Moses, as their singular human leader, feels the weight of this collective expectation and the sheer impossibility of satisfying it from his own limited means.
• For they weep before me: The Hebrew ki-yivku ‘alay (כִּי־יִבְכּוּ עָלַי) describes an intense, audible, and emotionally charged display. It's not just grumbling; it's a deep, lamenting wailing. "Before me" signifies that their complaint is directly aimed at Moses, holding him responsible for their distress, placing immense pressure upon his leadership. This weeping implies a deep self-pity and manipulative appeal.
• saying, ‘Give us meat, that we may eat!’: This is a direct quote, showing the precise, impatient, and demanding nature of their cry. The command t’nah-lanu (תְּנָה־לָּנוּ), "give us," is an imperative, revealing a sense of entitlement rather than humble request. The motivation "that we may eat" highlights their focus on immediate, physical gratification, neglecting any thought of God's past faithfulness or future plans.
• Where am I to get meat to give all these people?: This phrase captures Moses' fundamental problem: he, a human, is confronted with a divine-level responsibility. It is a moment of existential crisis for his leadership, realizing that the people's needs surpass any human solution, thus necessitating a divine intervention or burden-sharing.
• For they weep before me, saying, ‘Give us meat, that we may eat!’: This phrase articulates the immense pressure on Moses, caught between the people's relentless, carnal demands and his own human limitations. It portrays a scene of spiritual immaturity and demanding self-indulgence on the part of the people, who choose complaining over contentment and trust in God's established provision.

Commentary

Numbers 11:13 is a powerful expression of Moses' utter despondency under the crushing weight of leadership. He finds himself caught between the constant, overwhelming demands of a million ungrateful people and his own very real human limitations. This verse marks a pivotal moment where Moses’ faith, usually resilient, falters under the emotional burden of the congregation's persistent, manipulative wailing. His question, "Where am I to get meat?", is not rhetorical in the sense of expecting no answer, but rather a desperate cry, admitting total incapacity to God. It highlights the vast chasm between human weakness and the divine responsibility placed upon him. The people's focus on fleshly craving ("meat") signifies a regression from their divine calling and gratitude for God's faithful provision, putting pressure on their divinely appointed leader to fulfill carnal desires that only God truly could. Moses feels as if he alone must birth and carry this nation, a burden far too great for any man, foreshadowing the divine solution of sharing the Spirit with the seventy elders. This also serves as a poignant reminder that even great spiritual leaders are not immune to profound discouragement when faced with the insatiable appetites and ingratitude of those they serve.

Bonus section

• Moses' cry here is less a complaint against God and more a pouring out of his overwhelmed heart, recognizing his own limits in a situation only God could handle.
• This verse foreshadows the practical challenges of sustaining a vast congregation, issues that require divine strength and delegation, as God instructs Moses to gather seventy elders.
• The demanding nature of the people "weeping before me, saying, 'Give us meat!'" reveals a lack of spiritual maturity and reliance on immediate gratification rather than patient trust in divine providence, mirroring similar human tendencies throughout history.

Explore numbers 11 images, wallpapers, art, audio, video, maps, infographics and timelines