John 6:6

John 6:6

ESV: He said this to test him, for he himself knew what he would do.

KJV: And this he said to prove him: for he himself knew what he would do.

NIV: He asked this only to test him, for he already had in mind what he was going to do.

NKJV: But this He said to test him, for He Himself knew what He would do.

NLT: He was testing Philip, for he already knew what he was going to do.

Meaning

John 6:6 reveals Jesus' divine foreknowledge and purpose behind His seemingly casual question to Philip. Jesus asked Philip where they might buy bread to feed the multitude, not because He lacked a plan or solution, but "to test him" – to examine Philip's understanding, faith, and practical limitations, knowing all the while exactly what He intended to do to provide for the crowd. It highlights Jesus' sovereignty, omniscience, and pedagogical method of drawing out human perspective before demonstrating divine provision.

Cross References

Context

John chapter 6 begins with Jesus ministering on the eastern side of the Sea of Galilee. A great crowd had gathered, following Him because they had seen the miraculous signs He performed, specifically His healings (Jn 6:2). As Jesus surveyed the large multitude (estimated at 5,000 men, plus women and children, Jn 6:10), He initiated a conversation with His disciple Philip (Jn 6:5). He asked, "Where shall we buy bread, that these may eat?" This question, rather than a genuine inquiry for information, serves as the direct precursor to John 6:6. The historical context indicates the people were primarily focused on their physical needs and outward displays of power, while Jesus' questions and subsequent miracle were designed to point them to a deeper, spiritual reality—that He is the true "Bread of Life" (Jn 6:35). The testing of Philip here sets the stage to demonstrate Jesus' divine nature against the backdrop of human inability, and to introduce His role as provider, which later extends to spiritual sustenance.

Word analysis

• He said (ἔλεγεν - elegedn): This is Jesus. The imperfect tense indicates an ongoing or past action, referring directly to the question asked to Philip in John 6:5. It points to a deliberate and purposeful action by Jesus.
• this (τοῦτο - touto): Refers specifically to the preceding question Jesus posed to Philip: "Where are we to buy bread, that these people may eat?" (Jn 6:5).
• to test him (πειράζων αὐτὸν - peirazōn auton):
  • πειράζων (peirazōn): A participle, "testing" or "trying." In this context, it signifies an evaluation or a putting to the proof, to determine Philip's understanding, faith, or limitations, rather than to tempt him to sin (which is another, less common meaning of the word when used by God). It's a method for instruction and revelation, aiming to uncover what is in a person's heart and mind. God tests to refine, confirm, and instruct, not to learn for Himself.
  • αὐτὸν (auton): "him," referring to Philip. Philip was likely chosen due to his practicality and perhaps because his hometown, Bethsaida (Jn 1:44), was geographically close, potentially implying local knowledge for procurement.
• for he himself knew (γὰρ αὐτὸς ᾔδει - gar autos ēdei):
  • γὰρ (gar): "for," introducing the reason or explanation.
  • αὐτὸς (autos): "himself," an emphatic pronoun. It emphasizes that Jesus himself, uniquely and apart from needing information, possessed the knowledge. It highlights His self-sufficiency and divine insight.
  • ᾔδει (ēdei): "knew." This is an imperfect tense from oida, a verb primarily indicating perfect knowledge, an intimate and complete understanding. The imperfect tense suggests an enduring knowledge, that He already knew and continued to know prior to and during the asking of the question. This underscores His omniscience.
• what he would do (τί ἔμελλεν ποιήσειν - ti emellen poiēsein):
  • τί (ti): "what."
  • ἔμελλεν (emellen): "was about to" or "intended to." This verb with an infinitive expresses a strong intention or future certainty. Jesus had a definite, predetermined course of action.
  • ποιήσειν (poiēsein): "to do" or "to perform."
• Word-group analysis:
  • "He said this to test him": Jesus' questions are not always for His own information but often for the education, revelation, or proving of His disciples. It's a divine pedagogical approach.
  • "for he himself knew what he would do": This phrase immediately clarifies the preceding action, establishing Jesus' divine attributes (omniscience, sovereignty) and distinguishing Him from limited humanity. It underscores that His actions are always purposeful and never accidental or born of uncertainty. This contrast is central to understanding Jesus' character and mission.

Commentary

John 6:6 is a vital verse that unveils Jesus' divine attributes and His method of engaging with His disciples. His question to Philip, "Where shall we buy bread, that these may eat?" (Jn 6:5), was not borne out of uncertainty, but was a calculated "test." This testing was not to tempt Philip to evil, but to ascertain the disciple's understanding, reveal his human limitations, and deepen his reliance on Christ. Jesus already "knew what he would do" – He possessed perfect foreknowledge and a specific, divine plan to feed the five thousand. This highlights His omniscience and sovereign control over circumstances. The question served as a pedagogical tool, prompting Philip to consider an impossible situation from a human perspective, thus preparing him, and the other disciples, to witness a divine solution that transcends human capability. This prepares them for deeper truths about Jesus as the divine provider of both physical and spiritual sustenance. The verse teaches that Jesus often poses challenges or allows difficulties, not because He is unaware, but to mature faith and reveal His power and purpose.

Bonus section

The passage implicitly sets up a contrast between human calculation and divine provision. Philip's response in Jn 6:7, detailing the inadequacy of resources, vividly illustrates the human perspective that Jesus was exposing through this "test." This interaction is a micro-illustration of how Jesus often works: presenting seemingly impossible situations (the crowd, lack of food, Philip's calculation), not as a problem for Himself, but as an opportunity to reveal His divine power and draw His disciples towards a greater faith in His ultimate provision. This episode served not only to feed a multitude physically but also to educate His disciples about His true identity and their dependence on Him, laying groundwork for the more profound "Bread of Life" discourse later in the chapter.

Explore john 6 images, wallpapers, art, audio, video, maps, infographics and timelines